When Connie Gilbert began working for Consol Energy’s nonunion Buchanan Mine, the complaint for this class action says, she attended a group orientation that told new employees that if they worked for the company for ten years and reached the age of 55, they would receive retirement benefits for themselves and their spouses for life. Gilbert, who’d previous worked in a union mine, accepted these terms. In September 2014, she retired and began receiving retirement benefits. But, according to the complaint, in June of 2015—less than a year later—she received a letter telling her that her welfare benefits would terminate at the end of that year. The complaint contends that employees were repeatedly told about their “lifetime” benefits, to prevent them from taking offers of union or more lucrative jobs, and that the company should not now be pulling the benefits they earned with so many years’ employment.